I’ve just finished If Only I Could Tell You and I’m feeling quite frustrated. Not because I didn’t love this book because I did, but because of the crux of the storyline, the two sisters who haven’t spoken for nearly three decades, ripping their entire family apart. I want to rage at the misunderstandings, the mistakes, for nothing is ever black and white in families is it?
It’s the story of Audrey, and of Lily and Jess. Audrey is their mother and she’s had to witness the fracturing of her family. Only Jess ever knew why it had happened. Lily and Jess now have daughters of their own, born within six months of each other, cousins who could be close but can never meet. Very early on we learn of something that becomes the catalyst for matters to finally come to a head.
Hannah Beckerman’s writing is warm, it’s complex, it’s beautiful. It’s completely heartfelt but this is never a book that is twee or corny. It had me in tears more than once and when I thought I had an inkling of what might have happened Beckerman turned that on its head and dealt me a complete surprise.
What dawned on me right at the end as I thought back to what I had read was that this is very much a book about women. There are five strong women at the heart of it and only two men who feature in a very small way. It’s a story of motherhood, of sisterhood, of ruptures in families that can last for years.
It’s also an uplifting tale, particularly for Audrey who does something that she has wanted to do for years and it’s only now, when time is critical, that she does it. I thought it was wonderful to witness her living her dreams. Her main dream though is for Lily and Jess’s relationship to be repaired. I could only hope that her dream would come true.
Keep the tissues handy if you read If Only I Could Tell You. You must have a hard heart if you don’t feel anything. The flashback scenes are particularly poignant and particularly difficult to read, but also written with great care and sensitivity. This is a gorgeous read in every way.
Nicola Smith, Short Book and Scribes 5/5
If Only I Could Tell You by Hannah Beckerman
Orion 9781409177302 hbk Feb 2019